Penguin, 2008 (2008)
Read an Excerpt
Reviewed by Mary Ann Smyth
he London Telegraph touts
by Sam Taylor as '
Illusory and transfixing – a tender triumph.
' It is illusory ... and maybe transfixing, but for me - and I am definitely not an intellectual - it was confusing and hard to follow.
he concept is just short of brilliant – a man, James Purdew, who has lost three years of his life and is now trying to remember where those three years went and what happened during them. We wonder if he does find out, will he really want to know? As Purdew's characterization develops, it is easy to recognize a man who is in torment over those lost years.
he manner in which he recovers his memory lost me somewhere. Not sure where. The plot kept jumping from a dreamlike state to reality – or what the man felt was reality. But was it? I kept waiting for someone to jump into the text to loudly proclaim, '
' Though the ending cleared up some questions, it was too late then for me to care. I'm afraid that Taylor's technique in writing
was simply beyond me.
also have to declare that the prose was beautifully written, with descriptions and a sense of place that flew off the page to illuminate my imagination. I could easily visualize the foggy streets, the basement James Purdew occupied for a brief time, the apple tree that produced such delicious fruit and the various women he encountered and loved.
Listen to a podcast author interview at
Note: Opinions expressed in reviews and articles on this site are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of BookLoons.
Find more Mystery books on our
or in our book