Skulduggery Pleasant: And He's the Good Guy
HarperCollins, 2007 (2007)
Reviewed by Hilary Williamson
wasn't sure about the premise of
when I first heard about it, but a detective protagonist who's a reanimated skeleton really does work - trust me. This hard-edged hero is paired with Stephanie Edgley, a spunky twelve-year-old who may or not have magic in her own bones.
he book begins with the death of Stephanie's beloved uncle Gordon Edgley, who wrote bestselling '
tales of horror and magic and wonder
'. At his funeral, Stephanie spies a thin man in a tan overcoat with wild frizzy hair under a wide-brimmed hat, gigantic sunglasses, and a scarf wrapped around the lower part of his face. She's intrigued by this man with the odd name of Skulduggery Pleasant. Gordon's will, to the dismay of his greedy brother Fergus and family, leaves an ugly broach to Fergus's wife Beryl, his French villa to Stephanie's parents, and his mansion, assets and royalties to his favorite niece.
fter a breakdown of the family car and a storm leave Stephanie on her own overnight at the mansion, it's broken into by a frightening man looking for a key. When Stephanie is rescued by Skulduggery Pleasant, she sees him in all his skeletal glory, and hears the story of how he was killed in a battle against nasty sorcerors, but came back - unfortunately as a
bag of bones
- to help the good guys win the war. Now he's a detective who plans to look into the mystery of Gordon's death and to find out what Stephanie's burglar was after. Despite warnings of the likelihood of a horrible death, Stephanie insists on going along.
he learns the difference between
(Skulduggery is one of the latter), and accompanies him to a magical library where charismatic China Sorrows tells them that Skulduggery's old nemesis Nefarian Serpine has been enquiring about the mythical
Scepter of the Ancients
. The bony detective suspects that Serpine plans to bring back the
and destroy humankind. The race is on to find the scepter before Serpine's minions do, pulling Stephanie and Skul into non-stop action and violent encounters with a variety of monstrous creatures.
long the way - enlivened for the reader by the banter exchanged by the duo - Stephanie discovers her second name, and they gain allies in Ghastly Bespoke (a tailor, who makes Stephanie a new outfit), and ninja-like swordswoman Tanith Low. Unfortunately, Serpine has allies too, in unexpected places. But when matters seem most desperate, Skulduggery tells them (in words that reflect Derek Landy's martial arts background), '
There's no such thing as winning or losing. There is
and there is
, there is
... Everything in between is still left to fight for.
t seems like every new YA fantasy series gets compared to Harry Potter. Though I find most such comparisons ridiculous, I recommend
to fans of both
- it shares fast-paced action with the latter and a hidden magical world with both. Don't miss this thrilling start to a new magical series, starring (finally!) a brave young woman. Filled with the witty wordplay at which Irish authors tend to excel, it's enormous fun for middle schoolers and up.
Note: Opinions expressed in reviews and articles on this site are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of BookLoons.
Find more Teens books on our
or in our book