Munro Leaf & Robert Lawson
New York Review, 2006 (2006)
Reviewed by Hilary Williamson
y first impression of this classic
Caldecott Honor Book
, was that
is beautifully bound. My second was that Munro Leaf's story reminded me of the Irish Rovers' song,
The Orange and the Green
. Just like the Irish singer, Wee Gillis is torn between opposing sides of his family heritage. Robert Lawson's amusing black and white sketches bring the Scottish surroundings (and the boy's rambunctious relatives) to life.
ou see, his mother's relations are Lowlanders, who raise long-haired cows in the valleys. But his father's are Highlanders, who stalk stags up in the hills. Each group scoffs at the other's lifestyle. Wee Gillis alternates year by year with each side of his family, but what will he ultimately choose to be, a Lowlander or a Highlander? Each set of relatives tries to persuade him that their road is the right one for him. Trying to please them, he develops strong lungs - to call home the cows, and to hold his breath so as not to disturb the stags.
he day comes that Uncle Angus and Uncle Andrew demand his decision - when they get to the point of '
jumping and shouting
' in frustration, a very large man shows up '
carrying something brown and big
'. What he does next opens up a new life direction for
, in this simple and delightful coming of age story about family pressure, life choices, and the individual's freedom to make them.
Note: Opinions expressed in reviews and articles on this site are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of BookLoons.
Find more Kids books on our
or in our book